Faithwire
  • Watch
  • Go!
  • Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • News
  • Politics
  • Coronavirus Updates
  • Faith
  • Opinion
  • Christmas
  • Set Free Course

Matt Walsh Sparks Conservative Twitter Meltdown Over Proposed Pornography Ban

Photo by StockSnap/Pixabay
Photo by StockSnap/Pixabay
Share Tweet
By Will Maule
Author

December 9, 2019

Over the past few days, conservative Twitter has descended into complete and utter chaos over one apparently divisive issue: pornography.

Dr Pepper Prize Winner Shares Gospel on Live TV During Big Ten Championship Game

It all began when National Review staff writer Alexandra DeSanctis shared the news that four Republican representatives had sent a letter to Attorney General Bill Barr demanding that the DOJ make moves to prosecute the makers of hardcore pornography that meets legal standards for “obscenity.”

“The Internet and other evolving technologies are fueling the explosion of obscene pornography by making it more accessible and visceral,” the representatives wrote in their letter, which also served as a reminder to the DOJ about President Trump’s promise to roll out obscenity laws across the porn industry. “This explosion in pornography coincides with an increase in violence towards women and an increase in the volume of human trafficking as well as child pornography,” the letter added, according to National Review.

Quoting DeSanctis’ tweet, Daily Wire commentator Matt Walsh commented that this was “a great move” and that “conservatives who act perplexed at the suggestion that government might have a role in restricting hardcore porn obviously do not understand their own ideology.”

This is a great move and conservatives who act perplexed at the suggestion that government might have a role in restricting hardcore porn obviously do not understand their own ideology. This is, at the very least, an idea worth discussing. https://t.co/gMWWf1RRwS

— Matt Walsh (@MattWalshBlog) December 6, 2019

And at that, all hell broke loose and a three-day-long Twitter-based porn debate ensued. Among the sea of digital dialogue, Walsh has been taking a lot of heat from libertarian conservatives. Fearful of government overreach and convinced that Walsh is suggesting the federal government be invited into their most intimate private affairs, many appeared distinctly triggered — several even began lambasting Walsh’s views as “tyrannical,” prompting dismay from the commentator.

“It’s “tyrannical” to tell people they can’t post hardcore sex videos on a public forum where 11 year olds will access it?” he asked in response. “Tyrannical? Seriously?”

Other critics took a slightly more measured view: “Any attempt at a government ban on pornography would both violate the individual rights of adults and fail miserably in implementation,” tweeted the DC Examiner’s Brad Polum.

But Walsh, not to be deterred, went on to argue that explicit material should be controlled under the law in order to protect the eyes of young children.

This assertion prompted retorts from the likes of Fox News contributor Kat Timpf, who insisted that “with this logic, you are arguing that anything that isn’t suitable for children should be banned from the internet.”

To be clear: With this logic, you are arguing that anything that isn’t suitable for children should be banned from the internet. https://t.co/s4kWuOruMZ

— Kat Timpf (@KatTimpf) December 7, 2019

Walsh hit back: “No, I’m arguing that hardcore pornography has a specially significant and damaging effect on children, as many studies have shown, and the need to protect them from this harm outweighs anyone’s need to post their sex videos online.”

There’s no banning porn. It’s a useless thought exercise. But the number of folks saying “just be a good parent and it’s fine!” are mind blowingly clueless. I’d love my kids to be in a bubble but it doesn’t and can’t exist. Porn everywhere and it’s destructive. No easy answers.

— Bethany S. Mandel (@bethanyshondark) December 9, 2019

I find @SohrabAhmari and @MattWalshBlog persuasive. Conservatism TM has drifted way too far toward libertarianism. Limited govt does NOT mean zero govt. Social anarchy is a bad thing. We'll prob never get the balance exactly right by it's time for a course correction. https://t.co/WUBAw9SFXt

— Mo Reed (@mokatred16) December 9, 2019

As I lamented recently to a prominent conservative friend, the Right’s unilateral abandonment of justice-themed moral argumentation is one of the greatest political capitulations of the past three to four decades. https://t.co/9LPUwOt7Yl

— Josh Hammer (@josh_hammer) December 8, 2019

In a bid to broaden the debate and raise some of the most pressing concerns around pornography as a multi-billion-dollar-making industry, pro-life activist Lila Rose also weighed in.

“Regarding the debate on porn: It’s important to recognize there are two interconnected but separate issues — the production of porn & its consumption,” she tweeted. “The production of porn essentially involves prostitution. In both, people are paid to perform sex acts. Both violate the dignity of those involved, pervert the purpose of sex, often involve the exploitation of the vulnerable, & promote obscenity, which is NOT free speech.”

Twitter is a poor place to debate this (as it is to debate everything) but nearly every argument I’ve seen on this claims that conservatives want govt to make viewing porn illegal. No one has proposed this. Regulating an exploitative industry doesn’t infringe on individual rights

— Alexandra DeSanctis (@xan_desanctis) December 8, 2019

Others on the libertarian side argued that there should be no government regulation of the porn industry, instructing that “if you don’t like porn, don’t watch it!”

This simplistic rationalization was downed by DeSanctis, who tweeted, “’If you don’t like X, don’t do X’ is the dumbest argument plaguing public debate. ‘If you don’t like murder, don’t murder.’ ‘If you don’t like slavery, don’t own slaves.’ We can debate whether something’s harmful, but clearly government should enforce some set of moral norms.”

“If you don’t like X, don’t do X” is the dumbest argument plaguing public debate. “If you don’t like murder, don’t murder.” “If you don’t like slavery, don’t own slaves.” We can debate whether something’s harmful, but clearly government should enforce some set of moral norms. https://t.co/iBto5gzf0J

— Alexandra DeSanctis (@xan_desanctis) December 8, 2019

guess we shouldn’t bother trying to prosecute for murder or theft either huh since those are moral wrongs https://t.co/f2MjdJMxKM

— Alexandra DeSanctis (@xan_desanctis) December 6, 2019

Of course, the defense of one’s personal and private choice to view hardcore pornography is blighted by the fact that the industry deals primarily in coercion and sex trafficking. Yes, those defending it may feel as if they possess a right to watch what they like, but the sordid process by which porn is produced and the proven detrimental effects inflicted upon those who consume such explicit material cannot be ignored.

Further, as Christians, we believe there is a whole other side to this issue. When followers of Jesus view pornography, it grieves the heart of God. Plus, let’s remember that every single person involved in the sexual acts being recorded and broadcast to millions of consumers are also children of God. They are made in His image. To objectify them and use them solely for your own sexual pleasure is a grave violation of God’s commands.

Kanye West Replacing John Crist at Christian Youth Conference

However, we must remember, too, that there is hope for those entangled in the throes of porn addiction. As Walsh remarked, many of those so desperate to advocate for the continued production of hardcore pornography are likely addicted to the stuff themselves. Others, however, may be desperate to escape its toxic allure.

On this, we can help.

If you are fighting sexual sin or a compulsion toward pornography, Faithwire has a seven-week video e-course — Set Free — designed to equip you with the spiritual and practical tools you need to eliminate it from your life. If you would like more information about the study, or if you’re interested in enrolling, click here

Latest

  • Life

    Mystery Solved Surrounding Hero Who Saved Man From Burning Car, and There’s an Unexpected, Redemptive Twist

  • News

    ‘Absolutely a Miracle’: Teen Hiker Rescued After Falling Off Cliff in Georgia While Taking Picture

  • News

    PRAY: 14 Students, One Teacher Dead After Texas Elementary School Shooting

  • culture

    State Farms Drops Partnership With LGBTQ Children’s Book Program After Backlash

  • News

    Pelosi Breaks Silence on Communion Ban, Claims Pro-Lifers are ‘Rejecting’ Gospel of Matthew


Navigation

  • Watch
  • Go!
  • Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Staff
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Sign up to get our newsletter your inbox every day.

Newsletter Signup

Do you want to read
more articles like this?